Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Experimental Fat Loss's avatar

Haha, kind of funny to me how you're alarmed over 2kg in 3 weeks :) I routinely gain 3kg (6lbs) the first day when I stop a strict diet and go on a binge ;)

But sounds like you're making the discovery that a lot of people in r/saturatedfat are making - The Croissant Diet alone doesn't help everyone lose weight, and some even gain weight on it.

Suspects:

1. Just because PUFA put you into this metabolic state doesn't mean cutting out PUFA alone will reverse it/make you lose weight

2. It's not just PUFA, but PUFA + {BCAA,fructose} for example

3. It's not PUFA, but something else (e.g. BCAA, fructose)

Now even if PUFA didn't contribute at all, I'd probably still cut them out. I just don't see a reason, and it's such a small change where my diet already is.

But if you're seeing yourself gain weight eating like this, I'd consider still staying off the PUFAs but also cutting out something else. You could start with almost all carbs, and see how that goes. If that doesn't make you lose, you could cut protein down. Then you're basically at ex150 ;)

Just a thought. I highly recommend r/saturatedfat btw if you're on Reddit, it's really great.

Expand full comment
ショーン's avatar

This really doesn't seem to be working. Why don't you try a deliberately high PUFA diet, but without any refined, nutrient stripped oils?

Walnuts, sardines, chia seeds, sunflower seeds, pumpkin seeds. I bet you'll actually lean out.

Some relevant discussion:

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/260253803_Overfeeding_Polyunsaturated_and_Saturated_Fat_Causes_Distinct_Effects_on_Liver_and_Visceral_Fat_Accumulation_in_Humans

Expand full comment
12 more comments...

No posts